Darwin's argument
1.[3p] Why does the Origin open with domestic pigeons rather than with fossils?
Why does the Origin open with domestic pigeons rather than with fossils?
The answer is: They show that undirected variation plus a sustained bias in who breeds produces large structural change
The answer is: They show that undirected variation plus a sustained bias in who breeds produces large structural change
The answer is: They show that undirected variation plus a sustained bias in who breeds produces large structural change
2.[3p] What weakness in the pigeon analogy does Darwin himself state, and what fills it?
What weakness in the pigeon analogy does Darwin himself state, and what fills it?
The answer is: The breeder has an intention and nature has none, which Malthus fills with population pressure
The answer is: The breeder has an intention and nature has none, which Malthus fills with population pressure
The answer is: The breeder has an intention and nature has none, which Malthus fills with population pressure
3.[2p] Darwin's elephants increase at about 2.16 per cent a year. What is the doubling time, in years?
Darwin's elephants increase at about 2.16 per cent a year. What is the doubling time, in years?
4.[2p] A bacterium must increase fold to match the mass of the earth. How many doublings is that?
A bacterium must increase fold to match the mass of the earth. How many doublings is that?
5.[3p] Put Darwin's four premises in the order the argument uses them.
Put Darwin's four premises in the order the argument uses them.
Some heritable variation affects the chance of surviving and reproducing
Some of that variation is heritable
Far more offspring are produced than can survive
Individuals within a species vary
Show the answer
a, b, c, d
6.[2p] Naturalists in 1859 generally disputed Darwin's four premises.
Naturalists in 1859 generally disputed Darwin's four premises.
The answer is: False
7.[3p] Why is exhibiting living animals with pit eyes, pinhole eyes and lens eyes stronger than asserting the eye evolved gradually?
Why is exhibiting living animals with pit eyes, pinhole eyes and lens eyes stronger than asserting the eye evolved gradually?
The answer is: It turns a claim about what is possible into a claim about what actually exists
The answer is: It turns a claim about what is possible into a claim about what actually exists
The answer is: It turns a claim about what is possible into a claim about what actually exists
8.[3p] Which things did the argument of 1859 lack?
Which things did the argument of 1859 lack?
Select all that apply
The answer is: A theory of heredity, An account of where variation comes from, Enough time, given the physics of the day
9.[2p] Match each name to what they contributed.
Match each name to what they contributed.
Malthus
Wallace
Spencer
Lyell
the phrase survival of the fittest
arranged the joint reading at the Linnean Society
independent statement of selection in 1858
population presses against subsistence
Show the answer
Malthus: population presses against subsistence Wallace: independent statement of selection in 1858 Spencer: the phrase survival of the fittest Lyell: arranged the joint reading at the Linnean Society